I've read a few of the past posts and people have said that the sizing is off a little. I wear a 11.5 in most shoes but according to the sizing chart they use, they recommend i get a 9 to 9.5. That sounds awfully small to me considering the size shoe i normally wear. When I called and asked them the size, they said go with a 9 or 9.5. I told them i have a narrow foot and a high arch to which they replied "you have a odd shaped foot and you'll need to send us your measurements". So can anybody tell me what size i should order? i'm confused now and they aren't really helping me out. Thanks, Bert