I have no preference of SW films. I grew up watching ANH constantly on VHS.
It wasn't until '93 or '94 that I knew there were ESB and ROTJ. I was uber-freaked out by Vader's helmet coming off. I had a certain image of him and then they flip it around on me.
score:
ANH--****
ESB--****
ROTJ--****
Once TPM was released, I thought "Cool!!!!"
JarJar was cool to me at the time. He was the first TPM figure I got, followed by C3PO and a battle droid. I had *most* of the figures from the film.
Score:
***
AOCT came out, and I was "Sweet......is JarJar going to get shot?"
Well, he didn't. The hundreds of jedi was cool.
I liked it, but there were still a few things missing to me.
score:
** 1/2
ROTS.......well, the clone armor was cool. The fights were awesome, and it was great to see Mace fight like he meant it. Still wanted to see JarJar get basted a little.
Score:
***3/4
Total:
OT wins by 2 3/4 stars.
If they would ahve made the prequels with the same "feel" as the original trilogy, it would be ultimately awesome!!! If they had some sense of continuity, it'd be perfect.
OKay, I might have a slight lean toward the original trilogy. lol