Maul vs. Vader

Darth Maul vs. Darth Vader - If It Could Have Happened, Who Would Win?

  • Darth Vader

    Votes: 63 78.8%
  • Darth Maul

    Votes: 17 21.3%

  • Total voters
    80
  • Poll closed .
i don"t own a Vader suit but, I've had the priveldge of wearing one once. I had much more mobility in it than in my mando which is armored between and boba and jango. Look at what the clones can do in the in the movies, comics, tv show and even the action figures. A poor soul in a set of clone armor can hardly sit and breath comfortably.

real world wearability of our costumes has nothing to do with the unfathomable physics of the Star Wars Universe.

There's nothing I've seen or read about Maul and Vader that lead me to believe that Maul could defeat Vader.

Again, I will concede that Maul was better, faster and more manuverable than Vader and that would be an advantage if they were non-force using sword combatants. However, Force lightening aside, Vader was a powrful forceuser. Emensly more so than Maul even could be or desired to be.

Maul was simply the best of what was available at the time for Palpatines apprentice. He was honestly more of a Hand than a Sith Lord and as cool as he looked and fought, he wasn't really that cool of a character on the level of A/The Sith Lord. In fact, nothing about him ever led me to believe he had the ability to be The Sith Lord.

Vader had the potential to be the strongest Force user in the SWU but, his potential was never fully realized because of his damaged body. However, he had pure physical strength, greatly enhanced by his cybernetics, he was adept in the force to a great degree. Who cares if you can't shoot lightening from your finger tips that can be deflected/absorbed by a lightsaber or palm of a hand? Just use your superior force abilities to seize them, not even a throat crush per say. Just seize their body and not permit them to control it. Vader had and demonstrated that ability against many other force users. Although Vader's damaged body lacked the pur speed and skill he possessed as Anakin, he learned new techniques, generally relying on pure force and wanton disregard for self. He used his strength, size and power to overwhelm his enemies. Not to mention, he was willing to sacrifice damage to the cybernetic bodies to destroy his enemies, as was seen in the one shot comic where he took out a nest of Jedi trying to destroy him (Purge).

Maul is a force of nature but Vader was an unstoppable force of nature.

The scenario could go down multiple ways. Ultimatly, Vader would sense Maul coming and his intentions long before Maul was in any position to strike. Vader would likely let his over confidence rule him and bit and would likely attempt to best Maul with the Saber. However good as Maul was, Vader was too good for Maul to land a killing blow right off the bat. Vader eventually would become enraged enough to just seize Maul with the force and squeeze him to the size of a grape.

Endex = Vader pwns Maul
 
vadervsmaul2_1.jpg

You SO arent helping the matter...:p

:lol:lol::lol:
 
hey ,maul did kill a jedi, a jedi master at that. as he fought 2 jedi at the same time. so 1 out of 2 ain't bad. no ,he was not a sith lord ,maybe he was still in training.

that being said ,vader would make maul his (insert dirty word here).
 
read shadow hunter maul would destroy vader. and in follow up to my exar kun comment. Jedi academy is the run that cover and supports that kun is the baddest sith ever.

BUT..... I respect all of your oppinions I just disagree.
 
Exar Kun, Darth Bain, Darth Nihillis...I'd take any of em over Vader...he may have mastery of the force, but that doesnt count so much if the other guy can just resist yer attacks then hack you to pieces with a saber...

I'm with madmudder; i can respect all other opinions, just not agreeing with em.
 
ok i got to say some things. you killed a jedi master maul good job...one..one... id like to point out that vader, thats right vader B slapped like 8 jedi on his own, his own! maul has no chance. yeah so maul is faster,stronger, hades no! read vader's bio hes cybornetics increases his strength so any blow that maul tries to block would be like an elephant being thrown at you and only your hands to block you, that and vader is the chosen one he owns in the force, also for those who say his suit is combersome for him to move in,your right, but the bio also states that he has designed his own form of fighting to specifically compensate for that.vader wins, hands down. no animosity towards anyone i just feel that some of vader's fine points have been excluded
 
i would just like to point out that in the EU Maul is brought back twice. Once to hunt down Obi-wan and again to fight Vader. Outcome: Maul gets pwned in both fights. Im sorry to say but Maul is no match for a true Master of the force.
 
I do recall vader had to create his own fighting style to accomidate his armor. However........Vader got pwnd by luke come on people luke was lesser a jedi than most and he was not created by the force he was born to only 1 jedi and a meer mortal. I just dont see how "THE CHOSSEN ONE" could get skooled by LUKE. Thats like a youngling defeating Master windu.

Lets just tally up the votes:
PM me with Either VADER or MAUL
I will start the pole today MAY 5th and keep the pole open until May 7 8:00am
Rules: You can only PM me 1 time and must state either Vader or Maul and the word Winner.

Thank You,
MM
 
When it comes to agility, Maul is the best.

Vader being "Vader" all mechanical, can't properly duel with a lightsaber, he would loose, but why duel when you can kill your opponet at distance?

Vader is stronger in the Force, he doesn't NEED to maneuver that much to stop Maul's attacks, and then he would simply choke him with the Force, is that simple.
 
Come on now, Vader wouldn't lose an arm to a lightsaber. Remember when Luke hit him in the left shoulder in ESB and it barely scratched him and only ticked him off? I think this is the only occurrence in the movies of a saber not just cleanly slicing through an arm!
 
duuudes! you all keep saying vader is more powerfull with the force. that means he draws his strength, agillity and speed from the force... thus he is the badest and would win any fight with maul
 
This thread is more than 14 years old.

Your message may be considered spam for the following reasons:

  1. This thread hasn't been active in some time. A new post in this thread might not contribute constructively to this discussion after so long.
If you wish to reply despite these issues, check the box below before replying.
Be aware that malicious compliance may result in more severe penalties.
Back
Top