Comparison of Target and Nordstom Gloves

So I bought a pair of the Target Blue leather gloves today as a backup to my 2 pairs of the Nordstrom Rack gloves I got 2 years ago.
The glove on the righ is the very worn in Norstrom Glove and the one on the left is the new Target glove. The Target gloves have a leather strap across the top but easily cuts off. I bought the L/XL size and they are very tight but I expect they will stretch out over time like the Nordstrom gloves did. I also took a shot of my hand so you can see the size of my hand.

Nice side-by-side comparison shots. It looks like the Target glove is a more vivid blue. How is it quality wise, will it hold up to trooping?