Where is the BOBAMAKER Vs. MS Thread??????

[MediaGuyPJ]

I dont know about FP's stuff. I have never had the oppertunity to deal with him.

I am sure bummed I didnt get to see the culmination of the thread. I was reading it all day. I was way better than anything on the tube. LOL

At any rate Jordy and Daz are great guys alike. I hope this all gets resolved.

 

[Zeever Fett]

I am locking this thread guys, I have yet to see one helmet here...

 

[deadbolt]

Um...Here's one... lol. I hope the thread comes back, I missed about 3 hours of action

 

[stormtrooperguy]

i was actually impressed that the conversation had remained so mature as of when last i looked.

too bad it got pulled.

 

[Fett prop artist]

i was actually impressed that the conversation had remained so mature as of when last i looked.

yeah, I was quite suprised.

 

[fettpride]

It will be put back up. I don't think it will be "pruned". Nothing went that out of hand. Worst case, the possibility that it will be "read only".

FP

 

[Master Jedi Allma]

hmmmmmmmmm...
I wonder if there will be repercussions for those who made serious accusations in that thread if they are deemed unfoundered by TDH admin?:rolleyes

Mason.

 

[DarthMiller]

WOW!!

since I did not get to give my thoughts before it was locked.....

lets see Master-Jedi-Allma...you have a BOBAMAKER bucket being painted by AFFO$....yet you do not have a MS

I own a MS1, Held a MS2, currently own a MS3 and also painted a BOBAMAKER

I can tell you that all of the so called accusations are not accusations they are FACTS.....I have held the BM and MS in my hands at the SAME time for over 2 months and gone through all of the things FP outlined on his post with Spideyfett in my house. When you hold these two helmets you cant argue with what your eyes see. Now, I do UNDERSTAND that the pics provided (which by the way are of a BobaMaker I painted) are difficult to see what we are talking about but I can assure you when you hold them in your hands it is very clear.

I am not trying to say BM is a bad guy..he is a very talented artist and I have even considered buying his armor in the PAST but I do think we all need to be clear on just how his bucket was made. I would like him to comment on the CURVE/DENT in the RIGHT Mandable. How did that get in the bucket??????

anyway...I feel better now that I have posted my thoughts...no emotions and in my opinion this is a very civil discussion. I hope we all can be calm and keep this discussion going without it getting messy!!!

hmmmmmmmmm...
I wonder if there will be repercussions for those who made serious accusations in that thread if they are deemed unfoundered by TDH admin?:rolleyes

Mason.

 

[Master Jedi Allma]

WOW!!

since I did not get to give my thoughts before it was locked.....

lets see Master-Jedi-Allma...you have a BOBAMAKER bucket being painted by AFFO$....yet you do not have a MS

I own a MS1, Held a MS2, currently own a MS3 and also painted a BOBAMAKER

I can tell you that all of the so called accusations are not accusations they are FACTS.....I have held the BM and MS in my hands at the SAME time for over 2 months and gone through all of the things FP outlined on his post with Spideyfett in my house. When you hold these two helmets you cant argue with what your eyes see. Now, I do UNDERSTAND that the pics provided (which by the way are of a BobaMaker I painted) are difficult to see what we are talking about but I can assure you when you hold them in your hands it is very clear.

If it is only possible to understand what these apparent similarities are by holding both a MS and BM bucket in your hands...
then why has this been put into a thread in the public domain here at TDH?

Surely only a very small percentage of the 1,689 of TDH members have had the chance to see/examine/hold/own both buckets?...:facepalm

So why didn't MS himself, take his thoughts/findings etc etc...to TDH admin/mods and make his statement to them?.
Those of whom no doubt, would have been included within this small percentage and i'd imagine would also expect these sort of inquiries/accusations to go through them first for mediation between MS and BM anyway?

Why have these accusations been hinted/implied/stated etc etc... on the public domain in a thread that wasn't even originally about this?:facepalm

The way i see it is...
If you want to make it a public statement, then you have to accept the public's comment's, be they either for or against the arguement. simple.

Mason.8)

 

[welsh hunter]

I am totally with you on this one Mason. I own both a MS1 (purchased from AFFo$ in the cargo hold) and a BM v1 (purchased directly from Daz).

In fact, I'm looking at them as I type this thread yet I dont feel inclined to get involved in an argument which is frankly none of my business. This is an issue for Marrow Sun and Bobamaker to resolve.

All I have to say about the matter is that both helmets are excellent interpretations of the Fett helmet in their own right and I have nothing but the upmost respect for the skill and craftmanship of both makers.

 

[Jango Fett Jr]

According to the New Code of Conduct posted a few weeks ago:

Q: Why was thread “X” deleted/edited?
A: As with bannings, in the past we have often edited or removed threads without giving a reason why, which has also led to confusion on the part of the members. In the future, any thread editing or removable will be accompanied with a post regarding why the edit/removal occurred.

So I guess we should be learning why shortly.

 

[batninja]

In before lock!

 

[Ripcode]

Tagged for updates.

 

[evan4218]

Mason - MS did state that he had brought those points he made up with the admins. That was stated in the deleated thread. MS, correct me if I am wrong.

But I agree, that stuff is between MS and BM... never the less yesterdays drama was interesting to behold.

 

[Spideyfett]

Mason - MS did state that he had brought those points he made up with the admins. That was stated in the deleated thread. MS, correct me if I am wrong.

Yeah, some people see what they want too ....but he did say that.

 

[Master Jedi Allma]

Yes evan4218, your quite right!
He did state it in the thread as this exert from one of his posts on that particular thread quotes...

I have spoken with the Mods over this and like I STATED not IMPLIED, there's nothing thier willing to do over it.

So if its been dealt with in the past by MS and through the TDH mods...
has this then, not been put to bed already?:confused

Mason.8)

 

[Master Jedi Allma]

Yeah, some people see what they want too ....but he did say that.

Spidey... im sure your the funniest person on your planet!

Mason.

 

[Muad Dib]

So what is the helmet that is clearly being built from scratch (shot of the inside with sheet cheeks and a bondo-like substance in the top of dome) in BM's original thread? Did he offer a helmet before the current one he offers?

I don't remember and I'm just curious.

 

[stormtrooperguy]

So what is the helmet that is clearly being built from scratch (shot of the inside with sheet cheeks and a bondo-like substance in the top of dome) in BM's original thread? Did he offer a helmet before the current one he offers?

I don't remember and I'm just curious.

he did offer a different helmet. he recently came out with a revised sculpt.

 

[john django]

so any word about the thread coming back, I would like to see the helmets side by side..who has pics???:confused