I just wanted to stop by and give my opinion on something...

Brak, I understand your point. But as you stated a majority of the the TDH costumers are more interested in the aesthetics of the costume...then why are they even replying to this thread?

All I ask is that some of the attitudes of people change in regards to EU and non-canon related topics. Besides, the description of the Sarlacc Pit reads "general discussion forum"...meaning that the discussions don't revolve around Boba Fett and his costume.

I see many threads in this very Sarlacc Pit that are not related to Boba Fett, Star Wars, or even costuming, yet none of those threads ever get as much flak as when someone starts talking about Mandalorian stuff.

I realize that not all of you are "as into" Mandalorians as everyone else...but have members show some restraint with their comments.

My two cents. Delete it, lock it, do whatever. Just quit picking on the EU folks just because others aren't into it.

BigJon,

I don't think its a jab at custom Mandos or EU. I smarted off and I'm building Skirata. I feel the issue of this thread is that there was a complaint of sorts regarding the proper dancing style of a Mando dance (which is made up).

Once LucasFilm makes Boba dance in the live action series we could continue this debate.
 
Justify it however. I remember a bully telling me the same thing when he used to make fun of me at school when I was younger. "I was just joking with you". I guess you won't know how it feels for the ones being "joked with" until it happens to you someday.

I'm done here.
 
It is just a movie.. just a hobby.

Again, I don't think anyone is saying this stuff can't be posted, but you have to expect a LITTLE ribbing about it.

I definitely don't mind a little ribbing, it's completely fine. And those dancing SST's made me giggle. :lol: But when someone posts something like this, and more than half the replies are poking fun, that's a little out of hand. I'd say if you don't know what someone else is talking about, or you have no interest in it, don't post. Simple as that.
 
Maybe the use of Mando'a is a subject that we need to discuss on this board. I have had absolutely no ambition to learn this language or any of its words, but as it seems this is becoming a bilingual forum.

I would like to see the use of Mando'a to be discouraged, even in the custom mando section, being that a great majority of the members here don't speak a word of it and have no idea what anyone is saying; let alone how to pronounce it. Often I see when someone starts a run of an item, another member asks about it using Mando'a as if it's common knowlege, the one starting the run has to ask what was said before a real answer could be given.

Custom Mando's have their own forum now, Mando Mercs, and Mando'a there seems to be used just as frequently as English. Mando'a has crept onto this board, as well as clonetroopers.net.

Many members here don't even have English as their first language, and with them trying to learn that as well as having Mando'a thrown into the mix, this will really confuse someone. We have members here from France, Spain, Germany, Japan, China, Italy, where have you, many different languages, and I don't think a fake language needs to be mixed in when many of us are here just to build a costume; not to be a real Mandalorian.

So my final thought is that you can speak your Mando'a if you want to, I just don't like to see it, I have no idea what it means and no one translates it. Being in the South West I have to deal with this issue every day not speaking a word of Spanish. For all who use Mando'a, I would recommend that you explain what you're trying to say in English too.
 
The only part that I really have a hard time with is when folks post this mando stuff assuming that everyone will know what they mean.

Were this a Mandalorian community, they probably would. But this is a board dedicated to bickering about how superior the RotJ paint scheme is to the ESB one ;)

So as a result, there are lots of us that just have no clue what any of this means, so seeing a post typed in a language that doesn't exist to the world at large is just awkward.

And somehow I feel like we've had this very same conversation. Repeatedly :)
 
Justify it however. I remember a bully telling me the same thing when he used to make fun of me at school when I was younger. "I was just joking with you". I guess you won't know how it feels for the ones being "joked with" until it happens to you someday.

I'm done here.

Come on.... you are taking this way too seriously. As I said, we ALL laugh at ourselves, and at each other. You are comparing this to bullying? Really? Guess some people DO take this stuff way more seriously than others...
 
And to think... just a few years ago the RotJ paint scheme was on the dancing mandalorians side of the argument and the ESB paint scheme was the "bully." How times have changed...:lol:lol::lol:
 
Come on.... you are taking this way too seriously. As I said, we ALL laugh at ourselves, and at each other. You are comparing this to bullying? Really? Guess some people DO take this stuff way more seriously than others...

No, I think it falls along the lines of "Some people take different aspects more seriously then others.".

Just like your example of arguing over paint schemes here on TDH, we have some people who argue over words on Mercs. It's not that one person takes "Costuming" any more seriously then you do, but the aspects of TDH which is mainly a prop forum may be different from someone who is looking to know more about "Mandalorians" in relation to Star Wars. It's a hard line to see because as groups we are used to seeing certain things in certain ways. Like Obi Wan said, it depends on your point of view.

 
GET A LIFE its ok to like things and collect and everything but complaining about some made up religious dance(or what ever it is) common are you serious its like i cant believe im even reading this
 
Last edited by a moderator:
No, I think it falls along the lines of "Some people take different aspects more seriously then others.".

I totally agree with this. The thing is, I don't guess I would go over to a place where I knew it was all about "mandalorian culture" and try to force a point about how those guys aren't being "screen accurate" and if I did, I wouldn't be surprised at all if the general response was "who cares?" What I don't understand is that there are people who actually seem to be getting offended about this.
 
I don't think the OP knew in this case that this aspect of mando costuming wasn't discussed here.

TDH has a variants board where non-Fett mandos do post, and while it's not a board that is seen as a board to discuss "Mandalorians", it does mean that a door is open for EU discussion. Some people will see that and take it to mean TDH is a board for Mandalorian costuming and discussion.

The only advice I have for something like this is point them in our direction at Mercs if people come with questions such as this. It'll cut down on threads that are going to get possiable negative responses as well as keep TDH more on track with being a Fett/Zam props forum. To me, that seems like a winning alternative for everyone involved.
 
BigJon said:
BigJon
formerly joNich
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Leave TDH to the Elitists...
Posts: 579
e·lit·ism [i-lee-tiz-uh
thinsp.png
m, ey-lee-]

- Show IPA Pronunciation –noun
1. practice of or belief in rule by an elite.
2. consciousness of or pride in belonging to a select or favored group.
—Related formse·lit·ist, noun, adjective

I see no elitism in this thread. I guess not taking a made up language and culture seriously makes me an elitist. A great majority of the board doesn't take this language seriously, so I don't know how a minor subculture can call the rest of the community elitists.
 
This thread is more than 16 years old.

Your message may be considered spam for the following reasons:

  1. This thread hasn't been active in some time. A new post in this thread might not contribute constructively to this discussion after so long.
If you wish to reply despite these issues, check the box below before replying.
Be aware that malicious compliance may result in more severe penalties.
Back
Top