No one can answer that question for you. everyone has an opinion (especially about PP, it would seem), and everyone's opinion is going to be different.
All the info you need to help make the decision is within the posts, above. There's a commentary about the quality of the work (allow a bit more as they come up small, ask to see material first etc). Can't remember whether it's in this thread or another one where the PP jumpsuit was compared to Katara's (sp?) suit when a couple of the inaccuracies were discussed. Think it's in both, actually.
There's comment in here about the length of time they can take.
There's comment about allegations (and they are just that at this stage, it is worth bearing in mind) concerning unsavoury behaviour.
There's comment about the price.
The overall opinion appears to me to be that for the money, it's not bad. Bobafettish gives a good commentary about most aspects of the suit (colour, pattern, fit, etc) about 1/3 of the way down the thread.
Like I said, at the end of the day, no one can tell you, "it's the suit for you, go get it" as everyone has different standards. I doubt Braks buddy would be particularly interested, as he's a stickler for 100% screen accuracy, but on the other hand, when I first started out, I would have been thrilled just to have the suit. Everyones expectations and standards are different and you will be sorely disappointed if you are waiting for that answer to be given to you, I think. It is a decision only you can make.
E.g, someone who really likes it might post a response saying "it's great and everyone should have one"> that would be that board members opinion and it would be entirely correct, if that's the way they felt. Imagine the disappointment if you then ordered it and it took 3 months to get to you (and you wanted it in 2 weeks) and it had three flaps on the waist (and you wanted one, like the films) and the colour was light blue/grey (and you were doing RotJ and wanted grey/tan) and the short sleeves were a little too short. All these things would have been fine for the other guy, but would annoy you and you'd feel like you had been deceived and had wasted your money.
Alternatively, someone might say, "it's a pile of poop. Don't get it unless you're short on toilet paper". you might then not get it, spend twice or three times as much getting one from somewhere else and lose out on a lot of cash when you might have been perfectly happy with the PP one.
The info is all there. All you have to do is make the decision. As with most things, you'll have to strike a balance between accuracy, price, delivery time and reputation of the seller. Work out what your priorities are from that list and base your decision on that. Note that last phrase. It's YOUR decision.
Good luck all those who were seeking guidance.
Here endeth the lesson (sorry for the length of post!)
Back to scheduled programming.
Si